NOTICE GuildPortal will be going offline (permanently) by the end of the month.

GuildPortal FAQ

Frequently Asked Questions about GuildPortal Hosting

Q: I changed my welcome message, but it shows the same thing!

A nice feature of the Welcome Message is its ability to show a different welcome message for based upon the viewing user's member level (as specified in the Site Members section of the Control Panel). So if you change the message for General/Public members but you have a custom one for Super Admins, super admins will see the Super Admin welcome message, instead of the new public one. 

So when editing the welcome message look at the top of the page for "Editing Welcome For: (Drop Down Box here) .  Check each drop down area to see if you have any "Welcome Message" for that access level.  This could be why it seems to its not changing.